Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Bitter medicine

I wrote about the need for character in these troubled times, and hours later 'Helicopter' Ben obliged (would love to claim some credit for it!!). The US Fed has (rightly and bravely, in my humble opinion) ignored the 80% probability of a 25 bips rate cut that bond traders were betting on, and kept rates unchanged. While this probably means more pain for beleagured over-leveraged entities (like AIG?), it is good for the markets in the long run.

If I remember right, this (and the decision to let Lehman sink) is the first time that the Fed has signaled that it is walking away from bailing out failing institutions using taxpayer's money. This is good since it removes the obstacles from the forces of capitalism's 'creative destruction' - weaker firms will fail, painful de-leveraging will occur, and the business cycle will continue. Certainly this means more pain in the short term, but the writing on the wall is loud and clear - if managements of financial firms suffer from the same hubris or lethargy in dumping toxic assets / raising capital that Lehman did, then they too will suffer. This is good because it will prevent the buildup of insanely easy credit the next time around. Prevent? Maybe not - but it certainly should make a comeback more difficult.

At the time of writing this, the Dow Jones index has greeted the fed announcement with a knee-jerk 100 point drop. Looks like the behavior of a sulky child to me.

3 comments:

gayatri said...

Agree fully on BB not obliging failing FIs.
Nearly 200 point drop now.

Asha @ FSK said...

unf.. they bailed out AIG with a mega loan which effectively puts their BS at a massive risk.. which is worse than just cutting rates or govt backstops...

Kholu said...

I think rather than seeing a "creative destruction" we are seeing a "controlled demolition" of companies. I am not sure if Lehman was in a worse shape as compared to say AIG, Bear Sterns or Finne Mae and Freddie Mac, but yes it was surely less important and that's why Fed let it sink. The companies that will be bailed out are the once that went "Big" in words of Barry Ritholtz. Post bear stern bail out he said the message Fed is sending out is "Don’t just risk your company, risk the entire world of finance. Modest incompetence is insufficient—if you merely destroy your own company, you won’t get rescued. You have to threaten to bring down the entire global financial system".